Coronavirus: Public health professionals considered concept of moving Dublin to Level 4

Coronavirus: Public health professionals considered concept of moving Dublin to Level 4

The concept of moving Dublin to Level 4 of the five-level plan to tackle the increase of Covid-19 cases in the capital was backed by some members of the National Public Health Emergency Group(NPHET) at their meeting today.

But some members were worried Government would not accept such a dramatic relocation, which was supported by a minority of the team on Thursday, and instead advised a transfer to Level 3 with added constraints, as announced on Friday.

Concerns were independently revealed that recommending a higher level of constraints could trigger discord between NPHET and the Federal government, resulting in blended messages and weakening public health efforts to eliminate the infection.

On Saturday, Prof Philip Nolan, chair of the NPHET Irish Epidemiological Modelling Advisory Group, declined any idea, nevertheless, that the team would modify its recommend based upon the most likely Federal government action.

Members of the group think they might have to recommend an escalation to Level 4 in Dublin in 2 to 3 weeks, need to infections continue to increase– a move that would see the closure of all but necessary retail outlets with only essential workers enabled to travel to work environments.


There was also a discussion by NPHET that the entire country should be moved to Level 3 together with Dublin, but concerns were expressed that this would dilute the message needing targeted public actions in the capital.

If infection rates continue to grow significantly, the group might recommend a nationwide move to Level 3 next week, it is comprehended.

Last night, Federal government revealed the hardest constraints considering that the lockdown earlier this year, infuriating restaurant and bar owners in Dublin, a lot of whom say they are dealing with instant closure.

In a telecasted address from Government Structures, Taoiseach Micheál Martin warned that Dublin is at a “very unsafe location” and, without action, might quickly return to the worst days of the crisis.

Mr Martin stated he understood the havoc the virus was triggering to the economy, to sports, to arts and culture.

” However I also know this, my first and most important responsibility, and that of Government, is to secure you. This virus eliminates. It kills more old individuals than young, however it kills young people too,” he said.

Describing a few of the brand-new restrictions that would influence on the capital, Mr Martin stated visitors from only one other home will be allowed into houses. Sports training will be allowed to happen, but no matches, while weddings and funerals will be confined to 25 people.

” Lots of will be distressed by what we have to do however please be guaranteed these constraints are recommended by our leading medical specialists,” he stated.


Individuals have actually been asked not to travel outdoors or into Dublin city and county. Inquired about enforcement, Mr Martin said there would be an increased presence of gardaí on the roads but it would be left to people to be responsible in terms of adhering to the guidance not to travel into or out of Dublin.

Acting chief medical officer Dr Ronan Glynn warned that if action was not taken, the State might be facing 1,000 cases a day next month.

Dr Glynn said 1,600 people had contracted Covid-19 in the previous 2 weeks, there had been 17 deaths and the reproduction number was now in between 1.3 and 1.7.

” If we do not stop the transmissions now, we hesitate we could have 1,000 cases a day by the middle of October,” he stated.

Tánaiste Leo Varadkar stated lots of people do not want to think it, however the Covid-19 circumstance was “buckling down again”.

” It’s not all bad,” Mr Varadkar stated.

The Federal government revealed an immediate EUR30 million in assistances for businesses impacted, however hospitality market groups stated that would not be sufficient to tackle the crisis its members were experiencing.

Tourist sector

The Restaurants Association stated more than 50,000 jobs would be lost this weekend across the sector.

NPHET had actually thought about measures that would enable indoor dining to continue in Dublin, consisting of limiting numbers at tables, lowered capacity and earlier closing times.

However, in a letter to Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly in advance of Friday’s Government statement, Dr Glynn stated NPHET moved instead to advise the restriction on indoor dining “given the intensity of the epidemiological scenario in Dublin”.

Dr Glynn said NPHET’s view was “the profile of the illness in Dublin is at an incredibly important juncture,” and the window of opportunity to reduce the infection “without substantial extra measures is no longer readily available.”

” Once again, the NPHET fully appreciates that this newest recommendations will be disappointing, worrying and challenging for individuals of Dublin in specific,” he composed.

NPHET revealed on Friday there were 253 more cases of coronavirus, of which 116 are in Dublin, and 3 more deaths.

Of the 253 cases, 143 are men and 108 are females while 71 per cent are under 45 years of age. Forty-five percent are verified to be connected with break outs or are close contacts of a confirmed case.

Learn More Protection Status