Charging ex-Parkland gatekeeper Scot Peterson with kid overlook could backfire, experts say – NBC News
The question Florida district attorneys might have to compete with if former school resource officer Scot Peterson goes on trial for not challenging the gunman during the Parkland high school massacre came up Wednesday at his first court look: What exactly is a “caretaker?”
Peterson’s attorney Joseph DiRuzzo III argued that the criminal statute under which the former Broward County deputy was charged with 7 counts of overlook of a child and 3 counts of culpable neglect was not specifically prepared for police officers and is usually used to moms and dads. He is likewise charged with one count of perjury.
” The actions taken today versus my client ought to concern the American Public and every public staff member who, under the State’s misdirected legal theory, might be criminally liable for actions taken as a ‘caretaker’,” DiRuzzo stated in a news release Tuesday after Peterson was charged.
Florida Department of Police Commissioner Richard Swearingen insisted after the hearing that Peterson was “technically certified as a caregiver under statute.”
” So, when he failed to act, he failed to meet his duties of being a caretaker,” he said. “They decided there were 7 felony counts under that statute.”
But legal and police experts talked to by NBC said they’re not so sure about that.
” One of the elements district attorneys have to prove is that he demonstrated gross recklessness or wanton neglect for others or the security of others,” Celeste Higgins, a criminal defense lawyer and law teacher at the University of Miami, stated. “He may not have had a responsibility as a caretaker for the functions of these charges. Possibly the result of this is that it is going to redefine what a caregiver is under Florida law.”
Higgins said charging a law enforcement authorities for “not doing something is unusual.”
” Much will depend upon what standard procedure he was working with, what procedures he was offered with, was he trained to wait up until backup came on, what actions did he take when backup did arrive,” Higgins stated. “There appears to be some evidence that even after backup got here, he still didn’t decide to enter.”
NBC News legal analyst Danny Cevallos agreed that prosecutors might be stretching the meaning of “caretaker” to pursue Peterson.
Under Florida law, he stated, a “caregiver” implies a moms and dad, adult home member, or other individual responsible for a kid’s welfare.
And while Florida courts have acknowledged a “broad” interpretation of the term “caregiver,” Cevallos stated he’s discovered no previous instance of a school resource officer like Peterson being charged with neglect of a kid.
” Don’t forget that authorities officers have a degree of resistance for their main actions, too,” he stated.
California State University, San Bernardino teacher Brian Levin, who studies hate criminal offenses and walked a beat in Harlem as a New york city City law enforcement officer, stated Peterson’s “conduct was disgraceful and if there is a chargeable offense, it ought to be pursued.”
However pursuing Peterson for kid overlook may not be the finest way to do that.
” It’s possible that the Florida law might not be technically appropriate,” he stated. “However, I think legislators and cops experts are going to review the task of caretakers with respect to circumstances like this.”
” If the evidence showed that somebody had a legal duty to respond due to the fact that of their occupation and the particular vulnerability of a victim, I have no problems seeing that punished under criminal law,” he included. “The problem is where this particular law is expansive enough to allow for this sort of charge.”
Peterson, who was fired Tuesday from the Broward County Constable’s Workplace, was the only other individual at the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School with a gun when former trainee Nikolas Cruz supposedly burst inside on Feb. 14, 2018, and opened fire.
When it was over, 17 trainees, teachers and staffers were dead and another 17 were wounded.
Cruz is charged with 17 counts of murder and 17 counts of tried murder. He has actually pleaded innocent although his public protectors said he would plead guilty in exchange for a life sentence
Peterson, 56, was detained after a 15- month investigation that showed he “declined to investigate the source of the gunshots, retreated during the active shooting while victims were being shot and directed other police who showed up on scene to stay 500 feet away from the building,” the state law enforcement department stated.
Throughout a June 2018 interview with NBC’s “Today,” Peterson stated he did not enter into the structure since of miscommunication.
” I didn’t get it right,” he stated. “However it wasn’t because of some, ‘Oh, I do not wish to go into that structure. Oh, I don’t wish to face someone in there.’ It wasn’t like that at all.”
” Those are my kids in there,” he added. “I never ever would have sat there and let my kids get slaughtered. Never.”